These homemade waffle cones are quick and easy to make, chewy with crisp edges and have a sweet buttery flavor that’s reminiscent of a sugar cookie! Ice cream cones just ready and waiting to be filled with your favorite ice cream. Includes instructions for making waffle bowls and mini waffle cones.
Enter the waffle cone maker
I’m in love with a waffle maker. That’s right. I’m professing my love for a waffle cone maker. We got a Chef’sChoice Waffle Cone Express as a wedding gift, and I hadn’t even touched it until now.
Not that it’s not always ice cream season for me, but summer is the time when it’s socially acceptable to eat copious amounts of it.
And to do so, I need a delicious vessel for it because bowls just aren’t good enough for me. Why use the thing that’s made specifically to hold food for my food? Psssssh. I’d rather be able to eat said vessel.
If I’m being honest, a waffle cone for ice cream is the only way I want to eat ice cream when it’s not straight out of the pint container.
Are a waffle cone maker and waffle iron the same thing?
If you’re not familiar with waffle cone makers, they’re not the same thing as a waffle iron. So if you have a waffle iron and try to make this recipe it’s… well, it’s going to be terrible.
Waffle irons have deep grids intended for big, fluffy Belgian waffles.
Waffle cone makers have a very shallow grid – we want them to easily wrap into a cone and have just enough thickness to support our delicious, delicious ice cream.
If you try to wrap a Belgian waffle into a cone you’re going to end up with something that’s… again, just terrible. But turning Belgian waffles into a gigantic ice cream sandwich? I’m on board.
How to use a waffle cone maker
It will come with instructions and a description of the various settings, but quite honestly it takes some trial and error to find the ideal settings for you. For my machine, about 2 minutes on setting 3 is perfect for me.
It also comes with this cone form that makes it easy to wrap the thin waffle around.
Tips for making waffle cones
I recommend laying out a dish towel for the process because:
- That waffle is going to be piping hot.
- You probably don’t want to throw your piping hot waffle onto your bare countertop.
- You can use the towel to manipulate the waffle around the form and save your finger tips from certain burning
- It’ll nicely collect any crumbs so you can easily throw them away. Or eat them, either way.
Having the dish towel is also key to the “setting” process. You need to let the cone rest seam side down until it sticks in place as it cools.
You also need to make sure you pinch the tip of the cone closed. If you don’t, you’re just going to have ice cream dribbling all over you.
Hopefully I don’t have to tell you… that’s not a good look.
You need to let them cool so that they hold their shape, and my favorite way to do that is to gently place them in these vintage ice cream dishes.
You could always use a different kind of glass, or just let them lie on their sides – I just find this way easy and compact on my counter top. I just stack them inside one another, and I’ve never had a problem.
I like mine to be more brown than golden brown, as it makes them more crunchy than chewy – so I let mine cook for about 2 minutes on setting 3 on my waffle cone maker.
If you’d like yours less crisp and/or more chewy, just bake them for a little less time than I note in the recipe instructions.
How to shape waffle cones
Anyway, back to the waffle cones.
I don’t try to make them perfectly shapes, or with completely smooth and rounded tops. Per usual, I let them be perfectly imperfect because it’s way less stressful.
See that chipped one in the bottom right of the below photo? I broke it when I was moving stuff around, and SURPRISE.
It still tastes just as delicious as the rest of them.
How to make mini ice cream cones
Smaller cones means more of them! You can get more cones out of the same amount of batter if you reduce the amount you add to the waffle iron – just use 3 tablespoons of batter and you can 8-9 cones.
How to make waffle bowls for ice cream
You can use the same ingredients and follow the same process with the waffle maker, you’ll just need a different form for setting them.
When you remove them from the waffle iron, carefully place them inside a small bowl (gently folding and pressing the interior a little to make it fit) and let them cool completely inside that bowl.
I also highly recommend dipping the edges in melted chocolate – and maybe even some sprinkles!
Keep in mind: You still want to place them on a plate or in a bowl once you’ve added your ice cream! You don’t want to just stand around holding the waffle bowl by the base… it will end badly.
Also, these won’t be as thick as what you’d receive at someplace like Coldstone Creamery or the like – so you could even double up on your waffle bowl and set two of them together.
The magical waffle cone flavor
Speaking of the taste, let’s talk about the flavor in these waffle cones. Have you ever been to a Jeni’s Ice Cream? I’ve always loved the flavor of their cones because they have a sugar cookie-esque taste.
You could always use vanilla extract and omit the cinnamon, but my spin on Jeni’s recipe is my absolute favorite.
You know what else I love?
My new Erickson Surfaces photography board. I needed a larger board than the two I have, and I wanted to experiment with darker colors. I picked up their 21″ x 34″ in Cookie Sheet, with Farmhouse White on the other side.
If you’ve seen a similar background in pictures from posts in the past, it’s because I was using an actual cookie sheet. Unfortunately, I don’t think anyone makes a 21″ x 34″ metal cookie sheet, so… yeah.
Can you imagine the oven you’d use that in? ‘Cause I’d want one. Immediately.
Now that you have the recipe, what kind of ice cream are you going to fill yours with first?
Try filling it with one of these ice cream recipes:
- Loaded Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream
- Bourbon Butter Pecan Ice Cream
- No Churn Homemade Americone Dream Ice Cream
- No Churn Salted Caramel Swirl Ice Cream
- Salted Nutella Fudge Brownie Gelato
- Oreo Ice Cream
- Gingerbread Ice Cream
After you’ve made this recipe, please consider coming back to share your experience with others by leaving a comment below with a star rating!
Homemade Waffle Cones
- 2 egg whites
- ¼ cup heavy cream
- ½ cup granulated sugar
- ¼ teaspoon ground cinnamon
- ¼ teaspoon sea salt
- 1 teaspoon vanilla bean paste
- 1 teaspoon pure almond extract
- 5 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted
- ⅔ cup all purpose flour
- In a small saucepan over low heat, melt butter and then set aside to cool.
- Turn on your waffle cone maker to let it preheat.
- In a medium bowl, whisk together egg whites and heavy cream until combined.
- Add sugar, cinnamon, salt, vanilla bean paste and almond extract and whisk until well combined.
- Add melted butter and whisk to combine.
- Add flour and whisk only until just combined and smooth.
- Spray waffle maker with nonstick spray on both the bottom and top grids.
- Use a ¼ cup measuring cup to scoop batter into the center of prepared waffle cone maker, and cook according to the manufacturer's instructions.Note: For my Chef's Choice Waffle Cone Express, I find best results cooking on the Color Control setting 3, for 2 minutes.
- Lay a dishtowel on the counter next to your waffle cone maker. Once the round is cooked to your desired doneness, carefully and quickly remove it and place it on the dishtowel.
- Position the point of the form close to the edge of the round with the form resting across the diameter of the round. Use the cloth (to protect your fingers) to wrap one edge of the round onto the form, and then roll the cone forward until it's wrapped completely around the form.
- Hold the cone with the seam side down, gently but firmly, against the cloth and allow it to cool for 15 seconds or so. While it's cooling, also make sure you pinch the tip of the cone so that it's sealed!
- Once you feel like the cone has cooled enough to hold it's shape, carefully remove it from the form and let cool upright (I like to place them in these vintage tall ice cream bowls I have, or stacked in a pint glass). You can also lay them on their sides on a wire rack.
- Add your favorite ice cream and serve immediately. Enjoy!