No Chill Cookie Cutter Sugar Cookies

These sugar cookies are soft, hold their shape, are made in one bowl, and will be ready in 30 minutes – no chilling required! Try my chocolate sugar cookie cutouts next.

I love sugar cookies. And I love the flavor of royal icing (well – I love the flavor of my royal icing, which is why I’m sharing it with you). And I love piling sprinkles on my cookies and sharing them with others.

But I do not love having to chill my sugar cookie dough and wait, especially during the frantic holiday season. I need my cookies now, man! 

That’s why I’m sharing my favorite, tried and true sugar cookie recipe that requires zero chilling. This recipe has no chill.

… except for the fact that it’s completely chill, because it’s low maintenance and isn’t asking the world of you. It’s that friend you know isn’t going to cause a lot of drama, and don’t we all want more of those friends in our lives?

Of course we do.

Why these are the best sugar cookie cutouts

• No chilling! Do I even need to expand on that? That means no extra steps and no waiting, so you can whip these up in less than 30 minutes.
• They hold their shape during baking, so whatever you wanted them to look like when you cut them out of the dough is how they’re going to look when they’re done baking. 
• They’re study. They hold up well to being frosted and decorated with royal icing, making them the perfect Christmas cookie recipe.
• But they’re still soft! They’re sturdy, but they’re not stiff. You still get a soft sugar cookies, not something that’s going to crunch when you bite into it.

Making cookie cutter sugar cookies

• In a large bowl of a stand mixer or using a hand mixer, beat butter and sugar until well combined and smooth (about 2-3 minutes).
• Add egg, almond extract and vanilla extract and beat again to combine. You’ll notice the color go from a pale yellow to a more yolky-color.
• Don’t leave out or substitute the almond extract! That’s what’s giving these cookies their classic sugar cookie flavor.

• Add flour and baking powder (and a pinch of salt, if desired), and beat on low speed to start.
• As the dry ingredients incorporate, slowly increase the speed and beat until dough is combined and sticks together when pressed.

• On a floured surface (I like to lay down a large silicon baking mat), roll out dough with a rolling pin about 1/4″ thick.
• I like to use rolling pin rings (aff link) for this, because it ensures your dough will be flat and even – which means more consistent baking results!

• Use your favorite cookie cutters to cut out shapes and place them on your prepared baking sheets.
• Have a fairly detailed shape that could easily tear? My favorite method to ensure the dough comes out in tact is to wiggle the cookie cutter in place a little, and then tear the dough around it away.
• Keep in mind the cookies will not spread, so you can place them closer together than you would with other cookies.
• Re-roll the remaining dough (adding flour to your surface as needed) and continue cutting until you’ve used it all.

• Bake for 7-8 minutes – I find 8 minutes to usually be perfect. You want to pull them out of the oven when they’re not longer glossy, and before they start to brown.
• Let cool on baking sheet for 5-10 minutes, then transfer to wire racks (aff link) to cool completely.

Making the royal icing

I know a lot of people don’t like the flavor of royal icing, but maybe it’s just because you haven’t tried mine!

Almond extract makes all the difference in flavor, as far as I’m concerned.

You’ll start by combining all the ingredients in a large bowl – but make sure you’re using sifted powdered sugar.

The worst thing is having clumps of powdered sugar in your icing, leaving it clumpy, unattractive, and hard to work with.

Beat the icing on low speed to gradually combine everything, then increase to high speed to get it to the desired consistency. Then you can start portioning out the icing to smaller bowls to add food coloring gels.

But first, let’s talk about the different royal icing consistencies real quick.

Different royal icing consistencies

Stiff: The icing has been beaten to stiff peaks and completely holds it’s shape. Good for shapes like flowers and ruffles that you want to ensure don’t budge from where you’ve piped them.

Piping: If you lift the whisk from the bowl, the icing that drips back into the bowl will meld back in with the rest after 25-30 seconds. Best for piping letters, numbers and thin lines.

Medium: If you lift the whisk from the bowl, the icing that drips back into the bowl will meld back in with the rest after about 15 seconds. Best for piping outlines and borders, and can also be used for thick flooding.

Flood: If you lift the whisk from the bowl, the icing that drips back into the bowl will meld back in with the rest after about 5-10 seconds. Best for flooding, or for “wet on wet” decorating, like dragging a toothpick between two colors for a swirly tie die effect.

Icing too thick? Add a little water and beat it again. Icing too thin? Add a little powdered sugar and beat it again.

For the Baby Yoda cookies you see here, I decided to use a Medium consistency for his green skin and his clothing. He’s kinda wrinkly, and so are his clothes – so I went with the imperfect aesthetic. 

Side note: Have you seen this viral hack about how to make Baby Yoda Cookies? I didn’t have an angel cookie cutter, but I do have a mouse cookie cutter and it did the job!

I used a Piping consistency for his little eyes, though I probably could have gotten away with Medium for that as well. I didn’t get super detailed for the Baby Yoda cookies, so I didn’t feel the need to create different piping bags with different levels of consistency. 

For the snowflake cookies, I went with a Stiff consistency because I just wanted to spread it on with an icing spatula and be done with it (time crunch, blah blah blah). But also, I knew I was going to be topping them with some cute sprinkles, so what was underneath mattered a little less to me.

After you’ve made this recipe, please leave a comment below with a rating – and if you came from Pinterest, add a photo to the Pin of what you make to the pin to share your experience!

Print