Apple Cider Hot Toddy Recipe

5 from 3 votes

The classic hot toddy cocktail is easy to make, warm and comforting – which makes it the perfect drink when you're fighting a cold. The apple cider hot toddy is a sweet and spicy variation!

Two hot toddies in clear mugs topped with fruit garnishes

Pair it with a bowl of Carrot Ginger Soup, or make enough for a crowd with a cozy DIY drink bar alongside Instant Pot Glühwein and Peppermint Hot Chocolate Truffle Bombs.

Who's had their first cold of the season already? [raises hand]

My husband got sick and every day that passed was like watching a ticking time bomb. I knew that no matter how much we both washed our hands, no matter how much I sanitized everything he touched, and how long we slept in separate rooms (it's a quarantine situation once the sniffles appear, my friends)… it was only a matter of time.

I hope you haven't caught a cold yet, but in case you have – I'm here for you with the ultimate in cold-fighting cocktail comfort: hot toddies.

Specifically, apple cider hot toddies. Apple cider toddies? Hot cider and whiskey? Whatever we want to call them, they're wonderful.

Hot toddy in a clear mug topped with apple slice

Why do people drink hot toddies?

Rumor has it that hot toddies can help when you're sick. But why?

The traditional method is to include whiskey, and whiskey has properties for fighting off infections. It will also help ease you to sleep and act as a decongestant, and those are pretty much my main goals when I'm all pathetic and curled up in a blanket with the sniffles.
Honey has anti-inflammatory properties, and can help soothe your poor throat that's probably sore from all that coughing.
Lemon contains powerful antioxidants to support your immune system, and you need as much of that as you can get when you're laid up in bed.

Do hot toddies really work?

I think it depends on the person. Sometimes it's just what you need to clear you out a bit and soothe your sore throat.

Oh, and P.S.: Drinking more than one doesn't double up on its cold-busting powers, so take it easy and stick to just one.

Hot toddy in a clear mug topped with lemon slice and cinnamon stick next to spoon

Ingredients for hot toddies

Hot water, not boiling
Brandy, can substitute for whiskey
Fresh apple cider
Freshly squeezed lemon juice
Honey

How to make a hot toddy

Thankfully, making a hot toddy couldn't be easier – and I don't know about you, but when I'm sick I want whatever is the quickest and easiest thing to make so I can retreat back to my blanket and tissue-covered couch.

All you need are four ingredients and a mug:

hot water
lemon juice
honey
your choice of whiskey or brandy (or even bourbon)

Pouring apple cider into a hot toddy in a clear mug

But personally, my favorite way to make a hot toddy is to add one more ingredient: an ounce of fresh apple cider. It adds a sweet and spicy flavor, and really dials up the coziness factor.

Add a cinnamon stick and top with an apple or lemon slice (hey, why not both?) and get to sippin'.

I swear, just having an apple cider hot toddy in my hand makes me feel better already.

How to juice a lemon

Let's talk about my favorite way to juice a lemon to really get every last bit of that sour citrus liquid for the most bang for your buck when you're using it in your drink.

Start by placing the lemon on the counter and roll it back and forth, applying heavy pressure with your hand. This will help break it down and make it easier to juice!

You can also pop the lemon in the microwave for 10 seconds for the same effect – just make sure you don't heat it to a point of steaming, because then you're losing some of the juice you're working so hard to get the most of!

Four photo collage showing the proper way to slice and juice a lemon

Slice your lemon down the middle, width-wise.
Take one of the halves and slice off a little bit of the other end.
You don't need to take off a huge chunk, just enough to reveal the yellow flesh.
Place it in a lemon juicer with the wider part facing down, then press the top down and squeeze as hard as you can – over a container of some sort, of course. Don't just squeeze lemon juice all over your counter, that's not going to help anyone… unless you're cleaning, then just add a little baking soda and you're off to the races.

Overhead shot of two clear mugs of hot toddies

Variations

Add a little fresh ginger and lemon peel to the drink
Black Tea Hot Toddy – Prepare a mug of black tea, and swap that in for the 3/4 cup hot water
Fireball Hot Toddy – Add 1.5 to 2-ounces of Fireball Whiskey
Agave Hot Toddy – Combine 1-ounce mezcal, a teabag, and 1 teaspoon honey in a mug and top with 3/4 cup hot water

FAQs

How to make a hot toddy with apple cider

It's super easy – you make a traditional hot toddy, but decrease the amount of hot water and add apple cider. See the recipe card for the details and instructions.

What's a hot toddy made of?

Classic hot toddies are made with hot water, lemon juice, honey, and your choice of whiskey or brandy (or even bourbon).

What whiskey is best for hot toddy?

The best whiskey for a hot toddy is one that you enjoy the flavor of! In our home, we enjoy Bulleit Rye Whiskey and Monkey Shoulder Scotch Whiskey. There are plenty of other different kinds out there like Jack Daniels, Jameson Irish Whiskey, and Wild Turkey Bourbon Whiskey.

Leaving a comment and star rating is a great (and free) way to support Stress Baking. After you've enjoyed this recipe, click on the stars below and leave a comment to share your experience – thank you!